But I Won’t Do That
[Please forgive the Meatloaf reference. I couldn’t resist. And now I can’t get the song out of my head.]
Unlike several of my characters (Who’s thinking Sabine? You’re all thinking Sabine, aren’t you?), I have boundaries. There are some things I will not do, both in life and in writing. But since this is a writing post, I’m going to stick to my writing wont’s. You’re welcome.
The following is a list of things you won’t find in a Rachel Vincent book. (except that the formatting didn’t work out, and some of these bullet points are supposed to be sub-points. Sorry.)
- I won’t write vampires. I’m not speciest. I have nothing against vampires. I just have nothing new to add to the vampire subgenre, and I don’t want to write a book in which I have nothing new to say. That said, I did write a vampire short story once, for the Mammoth Book of Vampire Romance. I wrote that story for two reasons. First, because I was invited to contribute to an anthology, and I was very, very excited. Second, because I was able to find an angle on vampires that I hadn’t considered before. The vamp alternate universe, in which EVERYONE is a vampire.
- Would I ever consider expanding that story into a novel? No. Because the concept wasn’t well-thought-out enough for a novel. For instance, if EVERYONE’s a vampire, who do they eat? Riddle me that, oh vamp enthusiasts.
- Okay, I suppose they could drink animal blood. But that seems to be defeating the purpose of writing about the great human predator, right?
(Funny story: I missed the part about that anthology being a romance and I may have…kinda sorta…written horror instead. Then had to go back and squeeze in a little romance when my agent pointed out the lack.
)
- I won’t write gratuitous sex. Many writers are really good at writing intimate scenes, and that’s awesome, but that just not the kind of thing I enjoy writing. I wrote three complete adult novels without writing any sex, and only added an intimate scene in Stray (the third of those books) before it went out on submission at my then-agent’s behest. As it turns out, she was right, and the scene did fit. It changed something between the characters. And ever since, that’s been my literary litmus test for the “Will they or won’t they?” question.
- Does it change something for the characters or the plot? Does it mean something beyond physical gratification? Yes? Then yes, u can haz sex.
- No? Then no action for you. (None “on screen,” anyway. Feel free to imagine whatever you want. But don’t feel like you have to tell me about it. Seriously. Did I mention the boundaries?)
- Speaking of action, I will try very hard not to write gratuitous violence. Truthfully, I often fail at this. I’m pretty sure my editor has a stamp somewhere in her desk that reads, “Too much, Rachel. Dial it back.” I’m a dial-it-back kind of girl. What can I say? I love horror and action movies. I love horror and action books. And I like girls who can hold their own with the boys, even if they’re physically smaller or weaker. They can make up for that with stealth, speed, and enthusiasm. So I will try to write only the plot-necessary violence. But I make no promises. Which probably means this entire paragraph doesn’t belong in this list. But I’m leaving it anyway. ‘Cause this is my blog post.
- Most importantly, at least IMO, I won’t write easy-outs. No deus ex machina (god from the machine)—characters won’t suddenly be rescued from horrible fates by the miraculous appearance of a new character, a conveniently timed natural disaster, or the revelation of an awesome new power.
- No convenient deaths—characters won’t be saved from choosing a lover when one dies or backs out of the running. My job as a writer is to make their lives harder, then help them grow into the characters they need to be to triumph, not to make things easier so they never have to grow or change.
- In fiction, as in life, choices are hard and they have lasting consequences. Faythe’s dead loved ones won’t be coming back to life. In her world, death is permanent. Kaylee’s dead loved ones could return (because of the rules of her world), but not without steep prices and lasting consequences. Words can’t be unsaid. Actions can’t be un-taken. Forgiving doesn’t always mean forgetting. Sometimes your best isn’t good enough. Sometimes the bad guys win (at least for a little while).
Will there be some happy endings? Yes. Of course. I’m not trying to drive my readers into depression. But those happy endings must be earned by the characters. There are no trophies for second place. No consolation prizes. And in most of the worlds I’ve created, Miss Congeniality would be nothing more than an appetizer for the Big Bad (thank you, Joss Whedon, for the most apt description of a supervillan ever).
In my writing, characters strengthen and mature or they get eaten. Ask Kaci, from Shifters. Ask Kaylee, from Soul Screamers. (Or Sophie, in “Never To Sleep.”) Ask Kori, from Shadow Bound.
So what will you find in a Rachel Vincent book? Flawed characters doing the best they can. Characters making tough choices, then struggling with the consequences. There will be a lot of good vs evil. A lot of recurring themes (which I only usually realize in retrospect)—fighting on behalf of the weak, vigilante justice, strong (and sometimes twisted) family ties. And…humor. At least, I hope. I’m well aware that darkness needs the light for balance. I’m also well aware that humor is usually twice as hard to write as violence and angst (at least for me).
Now you know what I won’t write. What won’t you write (or read)?










I’m totally with you on pretty much everything–especially the sex for sex sake business. There’s nothing worse than over-description sexual scenes that dominate a story to the point you have trouble figuring out the plot. These scenes HAVE to move the story forward, if only for character/relationship development purposes, otherwise they have NO place being there. I also wouldn’t include a non-consensual scene. I’ve had a couple of scene that have made the reader wonder, just for a moment, if I’m going to take them there, but I’ve always pulled back before it goes too far–but that’s down to what I’m comfortable reading myself.
Vamps? I have included vampires in one of my novel but I would never have them as a main character simply because I don’t find them interesting enough and if you try to wander too far from the mould people get pissy that your vampires aren’t vampires. And yes, I have violence in my novels, but as you say, it can’t be there just for the heck of it and if it borders on gory then it’s wondered into the wrong book if it’s in one of mine. Total nastiness is not something I do–I don’t want my readers cringing at the pages.
Great post.
Great post, Rachel! I’ve noticed each and every one of these things in your writing before reading this post. I think it’s brilliant, because life IS tough, and people do die, and things happen that aren’t great, and you have to make choices that just suck. It makes your novels, despite being fantasy, so much more credible for the real life elements, and the humanity (Bean sidhe-ity? Shifterity?) of the characters. I love it!
I don’t write, so this is what I won’t read. I don’t mind some sex scenes, but I’m not into erotica. I just don’t like. I’ve read books where I can’t see how the characters are finding time to have sex when people are about to die. It just seems weird to me. And I’d generally just prefer the book to get on with the story. Too much sex bores me.
You know, I can’t think of anything else?
I challenged myself to write a sex scene once. It was the hardest, awkwardest thing I ever had to write. It furthered the plot considerably, but I quickly realized it just wasn’t for me.
Vampires are a bit iffy for me, since they became so popular and were nearly used to death.
I’m bad with violence. Fight scenes are the biggest obstacle for me. I have occassionally killed a character off, but I have a litmus test for that too. There has to be plot-furthering and character growth.
I’m bad at writing funny. Angst is just so much easier, so when I do have a funny story idea I have to jump on it because it’s so rare.
Personally, I love your characters. They piss me off like normal, flawed people (well, kind of people), but they also make sympathetic towards their plights to and hope for their happiness.
I am a newly self published author. So I am still trying things out but I can tell you I know my clear weakness. It’s got to be sex scene’s I am not great at them they either turn out weak or raunchy (ewww) so I go with very subtle hints and suggestions and that seems to work for me. Also I know I can totally do violence I also am a total horror, murder, mystery junkie. I am not so great at out right funny but I am good at making my characters pretty sarcastic. I guess thats me injecting a bit of myself into them.
This post is why we love you:)
Now, I’m too new to my writing to know what I would write but off the top of my head I agree with your “Don’t List”. I guess I would add that I’d have a hard time killing a child–I’m not sure I could write that.
As far as what I won’t read…horror that is the slasher type gore with no point or plot. Erotic sex with no plot— actually, I guess any story that features something for shock value that doesn’t have engaging characters and a good plot.
Darn you and the Meatloaf reference!
Apparently the way to get around a Vampire alternate universe is to give them access to a spaceship so that they can visit multiple planets and drain the lifeforce from them. Well, at least Tobe Hooper thought so in his classic space vampires movie Lifeforce…. Not sure how well-thought out that was either.
I’m with you on the gratuitous sex. I suppose when it’s expected it’s fine, but when you’re reading a book that’s 95% paranormal action, suspense, mystery and have that “obligatory sex scene” thrown in that is way OTT, it feels more awkward than sexy. I find myself cringing over those scenes, which feel as if the author was just as awkward writing them.
I’m a huge fan of action, violence and horror in books – though not reality based violence and horror. I much prefer it in a paranormal setting. I like the idea of a decapitated demon versus a kidnapped and tortured tourist on vacation.
I love the common threads you have in your writing. I think it’s what keeps me coming back again and again. Your heroines are strong, they’re not total idiots, weaklings, or overly reliant on others. But they’re also not perfect, they’re not super human and they don’t ring untrue, even if they’re paranormal beings that aren’t fully “real.”
Plus you do love to torment your readers, leaving us tied in knots throughout each of your stories. You are definitely the master of that craft.
Another great post!
I love your writing, and I read this when I saw your FB post.
May I ask a question? Would you ever consider writing about gay characters?
[...] hope I’m able to actually make it to Australia some time soon. —– Yesterday I blogged at The Deadline Dames, where I told everyone what you (almost certainly) won’t get in a Rachel Vincent novel. [...]
This is (one of the reasons) why I love your books – you write the most true to life characters!!!
I agree about the vampires, but that’s mostly because I find them incredibly difficult to write. They can’t go out in daylight! How does that not annoy other people?
I like your attitude that sometimes the bad guys win. It’s something I have trouble coming to terms with for my own writing. There were times when I was reading Shifters that I truly felt like Faythe never won anything. But the payoff at the end was so satisfying that it was definitely worth it.
Rachel, I was wondering, would you write a sex scene in YA? I don’t mean gratuitous sex, obviously, but for the same reasons you would in an adult book, if it changes something for the characters or plot? Or would it be something you “closed the door” on? I don’t mean the Soul Screamers specifically, but in any YA you may write. Some authors do, some authors don’t. I was just wondering whether the fact that the book contained teens or that the target audience are teens would make a difference.
El: Yes, I would and have written about gay characters in my Unbound books, though they’re not the viewpoint characters.
Jo: That would entirely depend on the context, tone of the book, and age-range of the intended audience. But at this point, I can’t see myself writing open-door sex scenes in YA. Perhaps the stuff leading up to and the discussion afterward.